1400–1511
Pre-Portuguese clove trade: North Maluku grows, Ambon passes it on
North Maluku (Ternate, Tidore, Bacan); Ambon/Hitu on the route
Before the Portuguese, cloves grew in North Maluku (Ternate, Tidore, Moti, Makian, Bacan) and reached Asia through Javanese, Malay and Chinese traders. Ambon and Hitu were a stop on that route; clove planting on Hitu only began around the 1520s.
What the sources say
Corrected after review. Asian trade in Moluccan cloves before 1512 is well attested (Villiers 1981; Mostert 2023), but the cloves came from North Maluku. Leirissa states Ambon-Lease produced no cloves in the first half of the 16th century; Mostert, citing Rumphius, dates the first planting on Hitu to around the 1520s and on Leitimor and the Lease Islands to the 17th century.
- John Villiers, "Trade and Society in the Banda Islands in the Sixteenth Century" (1981) — Inter-island exchange of cloves, nutmeg and mace for centuries before European intervention; Javanese traders collecting cloves
- Pamela Swadling, "Plumes from Paradise, chapter 2: The rise and decline of the Spice Islands" — Javanese, Malays and Chinese exchanged goods for cloves; Majapahit influence in the 14th century; Portuguese first in 1512
- Tristan Mostert, "Spice War: Ternate, Makassar, the Dutch East India Company and the struggle for the Ambon Islands (c. 1600–1656)" (1599) — Banda embedded in Asian trade by 1512; cloves first planted on Hitu c. 1520s, Leitimor/Lease only in the 17th century
- R.Z. Leirissa, "St. Francis Xavier and the Jesuits in Ambon (1546–1580)" (1546) — Ambon-Lease did not produce cloves in the first half of the 16th century
Catalogued as: Andaya (1993); Ricklefs (2008)